- The Coaches Coach
- Posts
- The Unicorn Phenomenon
The Unicorn Phenomenon
Why Exceptional Talent Defies Replication
The LAB Performance
November 22, 2024 • Reading Time: 6 minutes
The best aren’t getting better on their own,
they’re getting better because they are being coached.
Sean McVay - LA Rams Head Coach
When the Los Angeles Rams hired Sean McVay as their head coach at just 30 years old, many doubted he could handle the immense demands of the role. Yet McVay quickly proved his critics wrong, demonstrating an extraordinary ability to lead, strategise, and deliver results. His success didn’t just redefine expectations for NFL head coaches—it created a frenzy across the league. Suddenly, every team with a vacancy was looking for “the next McVay,” convinced they could replicate the Rams’ success by hiring from the so-called “McVay coaching tree.”
But this approach overlooked a critical reality: McVay isn’t a formula. He’s a one-of-a-kind talent, an outlier. Organisations failed to recognise that such exceptional individuals are the result of unique circumstances, environments, and talents that rarely, if ever, repeat.
This phenomenon isn’t exclusive to the NFL—it’s a common pitfall in leadership and performance strategy across industries. From business to elite sports, leaders often seek to emulate success by following proven blueprints, assuming that reproducing the conditions of past victories will yield the same results. But as seen in horse racing’s greatest legend, Secretariat, even exceptional bloodlines don’t guarantee greatness. Secretariat, often hailed as the greatest racehorse of all time, sired hundreds of foals. While many achieved success, none matched his legendary dominance. Like McVay, Secretariat was an anomaly—an extraordinary figure whose talent transcended any predictable pattern.
For high-performance coaches and leaders, the lesson is clear: success must be understood in context. True anomalies are rare, and replicating them requires more than mimicking what worked before. It demands a deeper understanding of what made those results possible in the first place.
Lessons for High-Performance Leadership
1. Define the Context Clearly
Understanding the context in which success occurs is critical. Was McVay’s success solely his own talent, or was it amplified by the Rams’ organisational support and resources? Similarly, Secretariat’s dominance came from a combination of his physiology, training, and race conditions. High-performance leaders must analyse the full picture and resist oversimplifying outcomes. Great results often come from unique alignments of talent, timing, and opportunity.
2. Acknowledge Sparse Data
Anomalies often emerge in situations where there’s limited precedent. McVay was the youngest NFL head coach to achieve such success, and no dataset could validate whether others with similar profiles could achieve the same. When considering untested strategies or talent, leaders must recognise when their data pool is too sparse to draw reliable conclusions.
3. Avoid Overreacting to Outliers
Relying too heavily on outliers can lead to poor decision-making. Anomalies like McVay or Secretariat can tempt organisations to chase patterns that don’t exist. Instead, leaders should prioritise robust, evidence-based decision-making and resist the allure of quick fixes or overhyped talent.
Embracing Context for Better Decisions
High-performance leaders understand that chasing anomalies without critical analysis is a gamble. While it’s inspiring to look at exceptional talent, the key is learning how to apply those lessons within your own unique environment. That means recognising that not all successes are transferable and that true leadership is about tailoring strategies to the specific needs of your organisation or team.
Great leaders and coaches don’t simply copy what worked elsewhere. They think critically, dig deeper, and make decisions grounded in their own context. By doing so, they move beyond the surface-level allure of anomalies and position their teams—and themselves—for sustainable success.
"The best advice
comes from people who don't give advice."
This newsletter serves as a compelling reminder that not all success can—or should—be replicated. Whether it’s Sean McVay redefining NFL coaching or Secretariat dominating the racetrack, exceptional results often stem from unique alignments of talent, timing, and context. For high-performance leaders and coaches, the key takeaway is to approach anomalies with curiosity rather than imitation. Instead of chasing patterns that may not exist, focus on understanding the specific conditions that enabled success and how they align—or don’t—with your own environment. True leadership lies in recognising the singular nature of outliers and crafting strategies that prioritise context, critical thinking, and adaptability over shortcuts or surface-level replication.
Coaches Notes:
1. Context Defines Success
Understand that every success story is rooted in a unique context. Assess the environment, resources, and circumstances that contributed to exceptional outcomes before attempting to replicate them.
2. Anomalies Are Rare, Not Templates
Recognise that extraordinary performers or results often represent one-of-a-kind anomalies. Avoid treating these outliers as reproducible models, and instead focus on principles that can be adapted to your own situation.
3. Beware of Sparse Data
When evaluating new talent or strategies, acknowledge the limitations of limited precedent. Sparse datasets can lead to overestimations of potential, so proceed with caution and seek broader evidence.
4. Critical Thinking Over Copying
Resist the temptation to mimic what worked elsewhere without understanding the deeper factors at play. Analyse success stories critically and use them as inspiration, not instruction manuals.
5. Tailor Strategies to Your Environment
High performance emerges when strategies align with the unique needs, culture, and capabilities of your organisation. Focus on creating conditions where your team can thrive rather than replicating another’s playbook.